the chewiest almond butter cookies {goddamn you, gwyneth!}

There was a time when I would devour the contents of my dinner plate within a span of two minutes. I was a marathon eater, a clock-watcher, an Olympian when it came to food consumption. I would eat simply to swallow, to move on to the next thing. Perhaps this comes from my childhood where I often wondered from where my next meal would materialize. Back then, you ate your food before someone else did. You ate your meal wondering if it would be your last. There was a summer when my family subsisted on potatoes, butter, and a hot pot. When we were flush, we feasted on chicken legs and quarter bags of cheese doodles from the local bodega–but these occurrences were rare. So now, even as I’ve been privileged to live a life of food abundance, I still flash back to my youth, and inhale every meal without being present.

Before my three-month program with my nutritionist/food coach commences, I’ve been really observing what I eat over the course of a day, and I often ask myself whether what I’m about to ingest will both nourish and sustain me. Am I savoring every bite and will the space between meals be less of a longing and more of a celebration, a siesta if you will? Otherwise, why bother. Why shovel food in your mouth just because?

Offline, I’ve been chatting with a lot of my close friends and have wondered how this demonstrable shift in my life will affect my baking and the kinds of recipes you’ll see here in the coming months. I have given this a lot of thought because I REALLY enjoy baking and the alchemy of ingredients, and the idea of photographing quinoa and chicken every day makes me CRY BUCKETS.

Then I had a thought. Why not make the very best pastries I can find {full-fat, full-flavor} as occasion treats, mixing in more virtuous desserts, which are not replacements for the sweets I love {don’t you dare talk to me about apple sauce in cakes because I’m not here for it}, but add a new dimension of flavor–desserts that take me to a new place rather than a revisit of the tired and old. It’s the difference between having homemade pasta with shaved truffles versus a box of dry noodles you dump into hot water.

Essentially, balance. Bake, but bake brilliantly and thoughtfully. Croissants mixed with these cookies and roasted veggies.

Now about these cookies. My friend Amber is over right now, and she can attest to the fact that these are THE BUSINESS. These chewy, rich cookies have no eggs, wheat, butter, sugar, or dairy of any kind and they are INCREDIBLE.


The almond butter flavor is pretty pronounced {you can use any nut butter, really}, and there is a smoky sweetness from the syrup, which pairs perfectly with the crunchy sea salt that christens the cookie. Honestly, these protein-packed cookies are a great treat for when you’re suffering from all the sugar cravings.

INGREDIENTS: Recipe from Gwyneth Paltrow’s It’s All Good cookbook.
1½ cups gluten-free flour (add ¾ teaspoon xanthan gum if flour does not contain it)*
½ tsp fine sea salt
1 tsp baking powder
1 cup natural almond butter {I made two batches, and in the second batch I mixed ½ almond butter with ½ peanut butter}
1 cup good quality maple syrup
1 tsp vanilla extract
½ tsp Maldon sea salt
*Note: I didn’t have xanthan gum on hand, and my cookies turned out fine.

Cover two cookie sheets with parchment paper.

Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. In a large bowl, whisk or mix all the dry ingredients {flour, salt, baking powder}. In another bowl, mix all the wet ingredients {almond butter, maple syrup + vanilla extract}. Add the wet ingredients to the dry ingredients with a fork and mix to completely combine.

Drop a tablespoon of mixture onto prepared baking sheets, ensuring that you’re creating small disks. Sprinkle each cookie with a small amount of Maldon salt. Bake for 10-12 minutes and cool on a rack before serving.


12 thoughts on “the chewiest almond butter cookies {goddamn you, gwyneth!}

  1. These cookies look delicious!

    Can I be a pain in the ass, however, and point out that maple syrup is indeed sugar? Once it gets into our bodies it will behave the same way as white sugar, brown sugar, Palm sugar, honey, or coconut sugar. I am not criticizing, just pointing out something that your nutritionist will likely point out too.

    I am happy to have all of the ingredients to be able to make these tonight!


    1. Not at all! Your feedback is super helpful 🙂 I actually really don’t mind that the maple syrup acts like sugar. I wouldn’t want a dessert that was completely virtuous, but it’s certainly a bit better than traditional ingredients.


  2. Just when I thought I had all of the ingredients, it turns out I did not have enough almond or PB. However, I am happy to report I DID have enough sunbutter! These little cookies are delightful!

    Just a sunbutter warning though. Expect your cookies to turn a lovely shade of green due to a chemical reaction. It may guarantee that no one touches these cookies but me, and that may be a very good or very bad thing!

    Thanks for sharing the recipe!


  3. These look good, and I definitely want to try Felicia! I had wondered what might change once you start your coaching. It’s all a great thing, of course, but I changed my baking habits.

    On another note, I’ve definitely come around to the thinking that I’d rather have some mind numbingly good chocolate/cake/ice cream than waste my time with lesser-fat/less-sugar options. That stuff is seriously for the birds anyhow, and tastes like utter shit. It never satisfies a craving. A well-made chocolate torte with quality ingredients? Heaven and satisfying.


    1. I couldn’t agree more. I often find that reduced fat substitutes are always packed with more sugar (defeats the purpose) and is never as satisfying as the real thing. Ultimately, I consume more of the crap because it doesn’t satiate me. Here’s to REAL FAT in moderation. xo


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s